Key takeaways
- A Guatapé country house asking about US$335K, let at the top of the short-term range, produces a gross figure that looks unanswerable next to a long-term tenant.
- It runs 0.3 to 1.2 percent of the cadastral value, and the rate depends on the municipality.
- Appreciation in the area has historically run 7 to 8 percent a year.
- Ask for evidence that survives being read by a sceptic.
- An apartment in Guatapé and El Peñol starts at around US$89K, with a typical asking price of around US$159K.
The common mistake is buying a luxury Colombian property at the short-term rental number and holding it on the long-term one. Short-term rentals have yielded 8 to 15 percent gross a year, long-term 5 to 9 percent. Gross is not net, and the gap between those two figures is where most offers go wrong.
This is not an argument against short-term letting. It is an argument against letting a yield range you have not tested set the price you are willing to pay.
Why does the short-term number flatter the property?
Because it is gross, and because it is annualized from the weeks that worked.
A Guatapé country house asking about US$335K, let at the top of the short-term range, produces a gross figure that looks unanswerable next to a long-term tenant. But the short-term figure carries a cost stack the long-term figure does not: cleaning between every stay, linens, restocking, a property manager who takes a percentage, platform commission, utilities you pay rather than the tenant, and the furniture and equipment you replace on a cycle measured in a few years rather than decades.
It also carries vacancy that is seasonal rather than occasional. In a weekend-and-holiday market like Guatapé and El Peñol, demand is not spread evenly across 52 weeks. A long-term tenant at a lower gross yield pays in all 12 months, including the ones nobody wants to visit.
Run both scenarios on the same property, with the same purchase price, and net them down honestly. Often the two land closer together than the headline ranges suggest. Sometimes the long-term number wins outright once you price your own time.
What holding costs should sit in the model before you offer?
Three that buyers routinely leave out.
Annual property tax (predial). It runs 0.3 to 1.2 percent of the cadastral value, and the rate depends on the municipality. That is a four-times spread. On a country house in the Guatapé and El Peñol range, the difference between the bottom and top of that band is a material line in your annual return. Ask for the current predial receipt, not an estimate, and confirm the cadastral value it is calculated on.
Closing costs you will not recover. Buyer closing costs run about 2 percent of the price: notary at 0.27 percent, registry at 0.67 percent, and beneficencia at 1 percent, plus your lawyer’s fee. On a finca at the Guatapé typical of around US$460K, that 2 percent is a real number you are effectively amortizing against rental income from day one.
Exit tax. Capital gains on a property sale are taxed at 15 percent when the property was held for two years or more. Build it into the exit assumption at the start, not when you are negotiating a sale.
Does the property that rents best also hold value best?
Not always, and this is the second half of the mistake.
A property optimized for short-term letting is often optimized for turnover: durable finishes, a layout that sleeps a lot of people, furniture chosen for replacement rather than for life. A property optimized for resale in a luxury market is optimized for the next owner’s standards.
Appreciation in the area has historically run 7 to 8 percent a year. That is history, not a forecast, and it is not a promise attached to any individual property. But it does mean that in this market the capital side of the equation has not been a rounding error next to rental income. Buying something that rents well and shows badly is a trade, and you should make it knowingly.
How do you verify the income claim before you commit?
Ask for evidence that survives being read by a sceptic.
- Platform booking history with dates, nightly rates and occupancy, covering a full 12 months, not a selected season.
- The management agreement, so you see the manager’s percentage and what it does and does not cover.
- Utility bills for the same 12 months, so you know what the gross figure is actually carrying.
- Written confirmation of the predial paid last year.
- The certificate of tradition and freedom, requested using the property’s registry number. It shows the registered owner, mortgages, liens and encumbrances. A property with a registered lien is not a property you can model income on yet.
Short-term letting also depends on land use and on whether the municipality and, in a building, the horizontal property regulations permit it. Land use is set by each municipality’s territorial plan, which determines whether a parcel allows country housing, subdivision, or agricultural use only. An apartment in a building whose regulations prohibit nightly stays cannot deliver the short-term range at any price.
What does the decision look like in practice?
Take the two entry points. An apartment in Guatapé and El Peñol starts at around US$89K, with a typical asking price of around US$159K. Across Antioquia, an apartment starts at around US$95K with a typical of around US$199K. A smaller, cheaper, well-located apartment is the easier short-term asset: lower cost to furnish, lower cost to replace, simpler to manage remotely.
A country house at the Guatapé typical of around US$335K, or a finca at around US$460K, is a different proposition. More to furnish, more to maintain, more grounds to keep, and a guest profile that expects more. These are frequently better held long-term, or used personally with letting as a secondary use, than run as a nightly business from abroad.
The Antioquia country house typical of around US$919K sits in a band where rental yield is rarely the main reason anyone buys. At that level the question is use and hold, not income.
Timeline and sequence
Closing normally takes 30 to 45 days once the deal is agreed. Do your income verification before you are inside that window, not during it. The certificate of tradition and freedom, the predial receipt, the booking history and the land use confirmation are all obtainable before you make an offer, and an offer written after you have read them is a different offer.
If you want a view across what is available at each of these price points, start with the luxury real estate colombia overview and work backwards from the hold you actually intend.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between short-term and long-term rental yields in this market?
Short-term rentals have yielded 8 to 15 percent gross a year and long-term rentals 5 to 9 percent gross. Both are gross figures. Short-term letting carries cleaning, linens, management commission, platform fees, utilities and furniture replacement that a long-term tenancy does not, so the net gap is narrower than the headline ranges imply.
How much property tax will I pay on a Colombian luxury property each year?
Annual property tax runs from 0.3 to 1.2 percent of the cadastral value, and the rate depends on the municipality. Because that is a four-times spread, ask for the most recent predial receipt and the cadastral value it was calculated on before you model any rental return.
What are the buyer closing costs on a property purchase in Colombia?
Buyer closing costs run about 2 percent of the price: notary at 0.27 percent, registry at 0.67 percent and beneficencia at 1 percent, plus your lawyer's fee. On a finca at the Guatapé typical asking price of around US$460K, that is a real sum to amortize against any rental income.
How do I verify that a property actually generates the income the seller claims?
Ask for 12 months of platform booking history with dates, nightly rates and occupancy, the management agreement showing the manager's percentage, utility bills covering the same period, and last year's predial receipt. Also request the certificate of tradition and freedom using the property's registry number to confirm the owner and check for mortgages, liens and encumbrances.
Can I run a short-term rental anywhere in Antioquia?
No. Land use is set by each municipality's territorial plan, which determines whether a parcel allows country housing, subdivision or agricultural use only. In an apartment building, the horizontal property regulations may also prohibit nightly stays. Confirm both before you price a property on short-term income.
What tax applies when I sell a Colombian property?
Capital gains on a property sale are taxed at 15 percent when the property was held for two years or more. Build that into your exit assumption at the point of purchase rather than at the point of sale.
Want to talk it through?
Tell us what you are looking for and your budget, and we reply the same day with real options.
Message us on WhatsApp →